cannabisnews.com: U.S. Senate Should Pass Forfeiture Reform Bill





 U.S. Senate Should Pass Forfeiture Reform Bill
Posted by FoM on November 19, 1999 at 14:54:40 PT
DRCNet's Weekly Update News
Source: DRCNet
In the war on drugs, law enforcement bodies ranging from the U.S. Justice Department to rural sheriffs' offices have themselves become terribly addicted to an intoxicating substance. It's not crack or heroin they're strung out on.
It's the money and property these enforcement groups seize each year from thousands of Americans under the often false assertion that the wealth is connected to the drug trade. In truth, these seizures have as much to do with padding department budgets as with keeping streets safe. And they trample fundamental freedoms enshrined in the Constitution in the process. Rep. Henry Hyde (R) of Illinois wants to rehabilitate our law-and-order officials. Mr. Hyde, no dove on crime issues, led the fight in Congress in June for passage of the Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act. The bill, now under debate in the Senate, would help prevent police and others from such acts as wrongfully seizing entire homes on little more than hearsay of drug involvement. It would stop the confiscation of cash and automobiles on suspicions of narcotics sales that are never proven and the taking of boats on discovery of a couple of marijuana joints brought on board by a guest without the owner's knowledge. As outrageous as these seizures are, they happen regularly in America under anti-narcotics statutes gone awry. Innocent people suffer great pain and loss without ever being accused of a crime. Yet this desperately needed reform bill is in trouble in the Senate. Ranking members of the Senate Judiciary Committee ­ Joseph Biden (D) of Delaware and Strom Thurman (R) of South Carolina ­- have vowed to kill it. They claim it would rob anti-drug efforts of a tool that hobbles dealers by taking their ill-gotten gains. But in truth, the Hyde bill permits civil forfeitures and recognizes their importance in the drug war while simply adding safeguards for the innocent. Currently, persons whose property or money is seized must prove their innocence at their own expense -- and without necessarily being charged of any crime. The Hyde bill would simply place the burden where it belongs: on prosecutors to provide clear and convincing proof that seized wealth is involved in wrongdoing whenever such seizures are challenged in court. So reasonable is the Hyde bill that it passed the House by a vote of 375-47, and was cosponsored by key ideological opponents in the Clinton impeachment battle. This unlikely coalition of supporters also includes consumer and trade organizations, the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Rifle Association. Nonetheless, the Senate Judiciary Committee threatens to derail the bill, thanks primarily to intense pressure from the Justice Department and the International Association of Chiefs of Police. They say the reform bill would allow dealers to file frivolous claims of innocence, hobbling prosecution efforts. But, as one House Judiciary Committee spokesman explained, this is highly unlikely given that any court challenge would expose a real dealer to legal "discovery" procedures that can be overwhelmingly damaging to guilty parties with something to hide. Yet the Senate objections persist, suggesting that it's the seized wealth itself ­- which departments are routinely allowed to keep -­ that is the real issue. Enforcement groups, frankly, are showing signs of addiction. Last year, the Justice Department seized $449 million, dramatically up from $27 million in 1985. In 1990, when the agency was falling short of its forfeiture projections, then-Attorney General Richard Thornburgh candidly warned federal prosecutors: Every effort must be made to increase forfeiture income. Steven Kessler, a trial lawyer who once headed the asset forfeiture unit of the Bronx district attorney's office, recently told the Associated Press: "Forfeiture laws have run amok. The focus is no longer on combating crime... It's on fundraising." It's time to break this dependency and stop eroding the rights of innocent citizens and debasing the Constitution. The Senate Judiciary Committee should send the Hyde bill to the Senate floor where most observers agree it would pass easily. Few bills in recent memory have enjoyed so much support from so many Americans for so just a cause. Mike Tidwell writes for the DKT Liberty Project in Washington, DC and is author of "In the Shadow of the White House," a book about drug addiction in the nation's capital. The Liberty Project can be found on the world wide web at:http://www.libertyproject.org/index.cfmForfeiture Endangers Americans Rights Foundation:http://www.fear.org/Click the link to read all of DRCNet's Weekly Update News:http://www.drcnet.org/wol/116.html
Home Comment Email Register Recent Comments Help




Post Comment


Name: Optional Password: 
E-Mail: 
Subject: 
Comment: [Please refrain from using profanity in your message]
Link URL: 
Link Title: