cannabisnews.com: What Have They Been Smoking in Ottawa?










  What Have They Been Smoking in Ottawa?

Posted by CN Staff on May 30, 2003 at 08:33:13 PT
By Rosie DiManno 
Source: Toronto Star  

Justice Minister Martin Cauchon should fire up a doobie and give his proposed new pot legislation a long, mellow think. Then bogart it. The bill, I mean.As is so often the case when politicians try to fix stuff, especially stuff that isn't hanging fire and doesn't require urgent attention, the federal Liberals have completely cocked it up, devising a jerry-rigged piece of law so illogical in design and contradictory in intent that it defies common sense.
No faction in the public debate — if such a debate even exists — has been pleased by the legislation as tabled, which is what happens when politicians try to suck and blow at the same time.The new drug strategy aims to dissuade Canadians, particularly youths, from using marijuana while simultaneously making it easier to do so; decriminalizes possession of small quantities of cannabis but allows for a whopping huge fine for growing just one itty-bitty marijuana plant, which surely comes as welcome news to traffickers worried about losing their clientele to patio gardeners; and considerately tapers possession fines to suit a teenager's allowance while extracting larger costs from adults, which clearly discriminates based on age. (So, what, get your kids to hold on to your stash?)How any of this would render the country's drug laws — soft drugs, of course — more sensible is beyond me.If health is the issue — and Health Minister Anne McLellan has reiterated that marijuana is harmful, thus will continue to remain illegal — then there would have been two clear options for Ottawa: either declare marijuana a weed non grata, with prohibitive possession penalties attached, or, more boldly, decriminalize it entirely, indeed decriminalize all "recreational" drugs, and deal with addiction as exclusively a health issue, concentrating on treatment and prevention, rather than as criminal activity.At least that would take the matter out of police hands, lop billions off law-enforcement budgets and free up the courts. But, oh no, that would be far too radical for Canada, or any other country where chasing the druggies has become inextricably linked to the economy. Just imagine how the colossal reduction of crime would wipe out the anti-drug industry, from trafficker to cop to prosecutor to jailer.The government has also put itself in the awkward position of mildly endorsing casual marijuana use while at the same time promoting oppressive anti-smoking policies. Might the day come when tokers will be tolerated in a public place — a bar, a rock concert — but smokers hunted down, forced to wear a charcoal-coloured star and exiled to a nicotine gulag?This is not so far-fetched an idea. In the pot paradise of the Netherlands, where marijuana is sold and used openly in "coffee" shops, hundreds of them, legislators are poised to approve a new law that would force tokers to smoke their joints outside, specifically to protect employees from passive smoke — and second-hand ganja fumes are a darn sight less passive than second-hand tobacco smoke. We're talking non-contact highs.Or maybe we want Canada to be more like the Netherlands, with half the population walking around blissed-out and stupid and shiftless. They don't call it dope for nothing.Canada won't straight-up decriminalize marijuana, nor legalize and control its distribution — as per alcohol and tobacco, as taxed products — because that would make Ottawa the "pusher," the same moralistic reasoning that makes solicitation of sex (but not prostitution, narrowly defined) illegal.Yet the cynic in me suspects that softening up the marijuana laws — issuing tickets instead of laying criminal charges for possession of up to 15 grams — has more to do with raking in the cash than sparing users a criminal record.Under this pot-bellied legislation, up to 15 grams would result in fines of $150 to $400 for adults, $100 to $250 for teenagers. Police would be allowed to use their own discretion — always a scary thought — for amounts between 15 and 30 grams, either laying charges that carry a maximum penalty of six months in jail and a fine of up to $1,000, or issuing a ticket for up to $300. But grass growers, even those caught green-thumbing just one to three marijuana plants, would be subject to penalties ranging up to a year in jail and a $5,000 fine. A 14-year prison max could be slapped against those growing more than 50 plants, or double the current top sentence.So, don't grow your own. Buy it down on the corner instead.This is the legislation the Liberals hope to enshrine in law before year's end.By comparison, the current law on the books — under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, contained in the Criminal Code — calls for a fine not exceeding $1,000 and/or a jail term not exceeding six months for possession of 30 grams or less of cannabis or 1 gram or less of resin. For any subsequent offence, the fine jumps to $2,000 and the jail term to one year.The new legislation makes no provision for increasing penalties for those repeatedly ticketed for possession. The existing law provides for a maximum prison sentence of five years less a day for possession of 3 kilograms, while trafficking over 3 kilograms is liable to life imprisonment. Never happens.Obviously, most people, given a choice, would opt for a fine over a cot in the hoosegow. Now casual users, including teenagers smoking up in the basement, need not worry about a jail sentence. In truth, rarely did the courts hand out jail terms for possession of small pot quantities anyway. But let's bypass the courts and go straight to the cashier's till instead — which is essentially what the proposed law is saying. The user avoids jail, however remote that possibility, and the government makes a tidy profit.Cauchon, in tabling the legislation, claimed that up to 100,000 Canadians are smoking dope daily. Maybe so. Statistics Canada figures show that, under federal statutes, a total of 19,539 possession cases went to adult criminal court in 2001, resulting in 11,517 convictions, 74 acquittals, 7,684 stays and 264 being resolved by some "other" fashion. In the same period, there were 15,729 trafficking cases, resulting in 7,327 convictions, 280 acquittals, 7,092 stays and 1,030 "other."Under the Young Offenders Act: 2,156 cases, 1,396 guilty verdicts, seven acquittals, 721 stays, 32 "other." (All these figures, however, as StatsCan admits, are seriously skewed because they don't include court cases tried under residual federal statutes — a total of 19,234 — mostly in Quebec.)It's impossible to speculate how the numbers will skew under the proposed new drug law. But what's indisputable is this: The government, talking out of both sides of its mouth, will be entering into an agreement that tacitly permits casual drug use, for those willing to pay the piper for the pipe. And with the government taking its cut.Far out, man.Rosie DiManno usually appears Monday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. Source: Toronto Star (CN ON)Author: Rosie DiMannoPublished: May 30, 2003Copyright: 2003 The Toronto Star Contact: lettertoed thestar.com Website: http://www.thestar.com/ Related Articles & Web Site:Cannabis News Canadian Linkshttp://freedomtoexhale.com/can.htmPlume of Confusion with Liberals' Pot Proposal http://cannabisnews.com/news/thread16451.shtmlU.S. Offers Help with Anti-Drug Campaignhttp://cannabisnews.com/news/thread16446.shtmlPot: Altered State - Surrey Leader http://cannabisnews.com/news/thread16430.shtml

Home    Comment    Email    Register    Recent Comments    Help





Comment #8 posted by afterburner on June 01, 2003 at 14:20:44 PT:
A Better Title...
might be "What Were They Drinking" since the resulting torrent of illogic in the recrim (decrim) bill is mind-boggling.ego transcendence follows ego destruction when the government stops championing the pharmaceutical companies and the treatment industry and instead meets the needs of the people.
[ Post Comment ]


Comment #7 posted by FoM on May 30, 2003 at 12:23:01 PT
MS, Marijuana and Me
Alison Myrden has Multiple Sclerosis. Her condition causes her constant pain, bladder problems and leg spasms. The drugs prescribed for her condition render her comatose. Instead, Alison chooses medical marijuana. Come spend a day with her and find out why. For more on the debate over decriminalization: http://www.cbc.ca/news/indepth/marijuana/
 http://www.cbc.ca/webone/alison/index.html
[ Post Comment ]

 


Comment #6 posted by FoM on May 30, 2003 at 11:36:04 PT

News Article from Snipped Source
Whyte Retailers See Decriminalization as a Growth IndustryJupiter Glass Galleria adapts to the times, now Jupiter Cannabis Culture Shop.
 
Nick Lees, The Edmonton Journal Friday, May 30, 2003
 
 
Hey, man, the times they are a changin' on Whyte Avenue.There's a cool new store selling marijuana paraphernalia.They stock everything from ornate glass pipes and 135 types of flavoured papers to stash boxes, scales and detox kits.You can't miss the Jupiter Cannabis Culture Shop. A two-metre-long Canadian flag in the window sports a marijuana leaf instead of a maple leaf."The Canada Day riot two years ago changed the demographics of the people who come to Whyte Avenue," says store owner Denyse Doran, 53."When we opened the doors of our Jupiter Glass Galleria 10 years ago, nothing but money walked in to buy items such as crystal glass figurines and Austrian Swarovski crystal jewelry."But now the area is filled with young people aged mainly between 18 and 25. They don't come to buy fine glass."She added: "I believe a Liberal government will decriminalize marijuana and catering to the needs of cannabis users will in future be a mainstream business."Doran and her husband Tom, 59, a drummer who played with Tommy Banks for 40 years, opened Edmonton's first head shop, The Hippogriff, in 1972.They launched a glass manufacturing business in 1974 and later represented glass artists, selling to 800 stores throughout North America."When things slowed for us about a decade ago, we opened our store on Whyte," said Doran."But our 28-year-old son Tom Jr. will now run the new store. Young people don't want to buy pipes from their parents."Snipped:Complete Article: http://www.canada.com/edmonton/edmontonjournal/story.asp?id=ACB5F8B4-CDA8-4F4B-8C55-FFCA2CB6CAAB
[ Post Comment ]


 


Comment #5 posted by FoM on May 30, 2003 at 10:58:51 PT

Wolfgang
I agree with you. Why aren't they writing about the Ontario court decision? I didn't see anything on NWI about it but plenty on decrim. Why? The longer I do news the more I don't like what I see.
[ Post Comment ]


 


Comment #4 posted by WolfgangWylde on May 30, 2003 at 10:42:30 PT

I really don't...
understand how any Canadian journalist can write about this topic without addressing the fact that the Courts have basically legalized simple possession. Maybe they think if they pretend it hasn't happened, it will go away.
[ Post Comment ]


 


Comment #3 posted by FoM on May 30, 2003 at 10:07:30 PT

Just a Comment
I've been looking and looking for news that says something more then has already been said and I'm not having much success. Where are the writers that need to say that this isn't going to work unless they deal with the growing issue. If a product is not going to be a big issue then where is that product to come from. If they think that increasing penalties is going to do anything but fill up jails then is that what they want? Do they want a massive Prison Industrial Complex like we have? 
[ Post Comment ]


 


Comment #2 posted by Commonsense on May 30, 2003 at 09:06:48 PT

What a Dope
"Or maybe we want Canada to be more like the Netherlands, with half the population walking around blissed-out and stupid and shiftless. They don't call it dope for nothing."I suppose you have to like someone who recommends legalizing pot, but I don't like how she mischaracterizes the situation in Holland. From all the numbers I've seen it appears that, per capita, Canadians already smoke more "dope" than the Dutch. Nowhere near "half" of the Dutch smoke marijuana. Even though they sell it out in the open, the Dutch appear to be less interested in it than the Canadians and the Americans who on average smoke much more marijuana than Dutch citizens. If she wasn't such a "dope," she'd check her stats before making such an allegation in print. 
[ Post Comment ]


 


Comment #1 posted by goneposthole on May 30, 2003 at 09:06:18 PT

new kind of fox hunt
Let the dogs loose and sound the horn.kill the chickens first, that'll teach the fox.Drug war insanity finds a new roost in Canada.a bird with acrophobia is a chicken. cluck, cluck
[ Post Comment ]





  Post Comment